The Permanent Unfinishedness of Intellectual Activism and Hope

A Critical Reflection on a Freirean Inspired Module Offered to Economic and Management Science Students

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.14288/ce.v17i4.187347

Keywords:

Capitalist realism, critical pedagogy, hope, intellectual activism, philanthropy, poverty, wealth, unifinishedness, critical management studies

Abstract

We present a critical reflection on a Freirean inspired module designed to develop critical consciences around sustainability problems. This reflection was provoked by a growing sense of disillusionment experienced by one of us, having delivered the module for over a decade. We used a sequential mixed method design to analyse a sample of assignments in which students reflected on their current socio-economic status and aspirations. We found that high frequencies of students aspired to be very wealthy and expressed an entrepreneurial spirit. Simultaneously, many expressed philanthropic aspirations. We suggest this indicates a dialectic juggle that students contend with as they become implicated in contradictions between wealth and poverty. This they resolve through philanthropy. While we take some comfort in the apparent emerging capacity for dialectic struggle, the popular philanthropy synthesis leaves us disappointed. However, we interpret this as an indication of the demiurgic character or “unfinishedness” of this work.

Author Biographies

Neil Eccles, University of South Africa

Neil Eccles is a professor in the Institute for Sustainability and Corporate Citizenship at UNISA. He teaches a module entitled Sustainability and Greed. His research interest is business ethics broadly defined, which he pursues from a critical perspective. He is the Editor-in-Chief of the African Journal of Business Ethics.  https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5845-5946

Chimene Nukunah, School for International Training

Chimene Nukunah (https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7051-8735) was the academic director for the Development and Social Change Programme at the School for International Training based in Cameroon. Her research focused on management education emphasising critical and decoloniality perspectives. In January 2026, Nukunah passed away following a long struggle with breast cancer.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-17

Issue

Section

Articles