“A Funtastic Columbus Day”

Analyzing Depictions of Christopher Columbus on TeachersPayTeachers

Authors

  • Maggie M. Rivera University of Chicago
  • Eve Ewing University of Chicago

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.14288/ce.v17i4.187341

Keywords:

social studies, holidays, Christopher Columbus, K-12, teachers pay teachers, curriculum

Abstract

Amidst public controversy about how history should be understood, interpreted, and taught, Christopher Columbus has emerged as a particularly controversial character. After decades of dissent and debate over Columbus’s legacy and his place in curricula, how do teachers represent him in the everyday context of the classroom? In this study, we analyze depictions of Christopher Columbus in curriculum materials posted on Teachers Pay Teachers (TPT), a widely-used online forum for crowdsourced educational materials. We present a hybrid (deductive-inductive) content analysis in which we analyzed representations of Columbus in 3,212 lesson materials posted on TPT. Despite ongoing calls for classroom materials that are more critical of Columbus’s legacy, and the unique potential of teacher-generated online materials to meet such demands, we find that these materials instead mostly reinscribe favorable images of Columbus. We close with a discussion of the role that teachers themselves—rather than only public commentators or textbook designers—can play in either upending or reproducing Columbus Day narratives.

Author Biographies

Maggie M. Rivera, University of Chicago

Maggie M. Rivera is a scholar-advocate dedicated to understanding the way schools, neighborhoods, and community-based organizations function as spaces of public memory and collective healing. She graduated with interdisciplinary bachelor’s and master’s degrees in the social sciences from the University of Chicago in 2024. Her research, published in South Side Weekly and Chicago Studies Annual (forthcoming, 2027), discusses the ways Chicago’s 2013 school closings impacted the Chicago neighbors’ responses to the emergency migrant shelter system in 2022-24. She currently works with survivors of torture to improve methods of holistic, trauma-informed care at the Marjorie Kovler Center.

Eve Ewing, University of Chicago

Eve L. Ewing is an Associate Professor in the Department of Race, Diaspora, and Indigeneity at the University of Chicago, where she is also an associate faculty member in the Department of Sociology. In her research and teaching, she uses multi-genre storytelling, tools of sociological inquiry, archives, and community-grounded epistemologies to interrogate racialized histories and imagine emancipatory possibilities. She is the author of several books, including Original Sins: The (Mis)education of Black and Native Children and the Construction of American Racism.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-17

Issue

Section

Articles